How does State Bar AI Opinions treat AI-generated work, and what record supports review?

State Bar AI Opinions sets the bar an AI output must clear before a tribunal or a client relies on it — reliability, candor, competence. Planisphere supplies the reliability record: a reproducible measurement of the system that produced the output, the thing the rule says you must be able to show.

00 ·

State Bar AI Opinions — capability brief.

Register 09 · Compliance pins · brief v0.1

Prepare evidence for compliance review Verify a record

Planisphere's evidence record answers State Bar AI Opinions's evidentiary asks via the Astrolabe schema. The mapping is published, reproducible byte-for-byte on customer hardware, and re-verifiable by any third party with the same inputs.

01 ·

Scope.

What this brief covers and what it does not.

In scope. CA · FL · TX · NY · PA · NC bar gen-AI ethics guidance roundup. Cite-anchor: State Bar AI Opinions.

Out of scope. Production data (no PHI, no PII, no student record, no privileged correspondence). Model weights. Customer's own analyses of the evidence record.

Boundary. Only sha-pinned, Merkle-rooted derived metadata crosses; model state never does. U.S. provisional patent No. 64/073,668 covers the property.

02 ·

Evidence.

What the evidence record proves against this anchor.

Every measurement against State Bar AI Opinions lands in a signed evidence record: each artifact carries its own SHA-256, the artifacts chain into a Merkle root, and the engine version is pinned alongside. Internal or external compliance recomputes the root and checks the record — without the model state ever crossing the boundary.

Prepare evidence for legal AI review →See how a record is checked

03 ·

Limitations.

Stated up front; ask a vendor that won't.

Planisphere measures behaviour, not capability. The evidence record says this is what your fleet did against the probe set; it does not say this is what your fleet will do under adversarial pressure. Adversarial coverage is a scope expansion that adds a probe family; the engine and the record shape do not change.

Reproducibility requires the inputs to be preserved. The record pins the inputs by SHA; it does not host them.

04 ·

Reproducibility & compliance check.

How a third party recomputes the record bit-for-bit.

Open the evidence check. Drop ATTESTATION.json and the named artifacts. The browser recomputes each per-artifact SHA-256 and the chained Merkle root via Web Crypto. Files do not leave the tab.

For a synthetic 3-subject record, see how a record is checked: one click checks an intact record; one click checks a tampered record and names the failing file.

05 ·

Cite.

How to reference this brief.

Planisphere Corp., State Bar AI Opinions — capability brief, v0.1, https://www.planisphere.ooo/corpus/state-bar-ai-opinions/brief. Methodology preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.20372606.

Open scoping for State Bar AI Opinions Reference